2024-11-21 15:17:00
He national deputy Alvaro Martinezmember of the Freedom Advances (LLA)recently presented a bill which seeks to significantly modify article 4 of the Gender Identity Law (Law No. 26,743), promulgated on May 24, 2012. The initiative proposes the prohibition of gender change in official documents both for minors under 18 years of age and for adults who have final criminal convictions.
Martínez explained that the main objective of his proposal is to safeguard minors from impulsive decisions related to their gender identity. Arguing that these decisions could be influenced by external factors such as the social or media environment. According to the deputy, it is crucial that such modifications are made in adulthood, when the person has the necessary maturity to define their identity consciously and deliberately.
Additionally, the project seeks to prevent individuals with criminal convictions from changing their gender identity. According to Martínez, it could complicate the functioning of the judicial system and be used to evade legal responsibilities. The Mendoza legislator emphasized that this provision is intended to guarantee public safety and maintain transparency in judicial processes, preventing possible abuses of the legal system.
Regulation of regulations
Martínez’s initiative arises in a context of intense discussions about the relationship between gender self-perception and its legal regulation. From LLA, it has been pointed out that the proposal aims to establish a clearer and more robust regulatory framework around gender identity, ensuring that decisions in this area are aligned with criteria of legal security and psychological maturity. Martínez highlighted that the current regulations could generate legal loopholes that put both the people involved and the system as a whole at risk. For example, underlining the importance of protecting minors from decisions that could have significant emotional and psychological consequences.
In his presentation, the deputy mentioned specific cases where gender change has been used to obtain procedural benefits or evade penalties. As in the case of certain femicides where the accused claimed to have perceived themselves as women to reduce the severity of the sentences. Martínez argued that these practices compromise the integrity of the judicial system. And they also erode society’s trust in legal institutions.
Modifications to the law
The project establishes a series of requirements to proceed with the gender change in official documents. Among them is the minimum age of eighteen years, the formal submission of an application to the National Registry of Persons, and the expression of the new chosen first name. Furthermore, people who have been convicted with a final sentence will not be able to request registration rectification until they have served the entire sentence imposed. For foreigners with legal residence in Argentina, it is also stipulated that they must not have final convictions in national or foreign courts to be able to request a change of gender identity.
Martínez’s proposal has generated a wide range of reactions in different sectors. Organizations defending the rights of trans people have expressed concern about the implications that this modification could have on freedom of identity and possible discrimination. Experts in human rights and mental health have questioned the scientific and ethical foundation of the project. Arguing that restricting gender reassignment could negatively affect the health and well-being of trans people.
Support of the legislative bloc
LLA representatives have defended the initiative, highlighting the need to establish clear criteria that ensure integrity and transparency in identity change processes. A spokesperson for the bloc declared that it is key that public policies in this area are based on principles of legal security and social protection. Ensuring that decisions related to gender identity are made responsibly and with due consideration of their implications.
1732202255
#deputy #Libertad #Avanza #presented #project #prohibit #gender #change #minors #adults #final #convictions
What specific psychological and legal criteria does Deputy Alvaro Martinez propose for individuals seeking to change their gender on official documents, and how are these criteria justified in the context of safeguarding minors?
### Interview with Alvaro Martinez: Proposed Changes to the Gender Identity Law
**Interviewer:** Thank you for joining us today, Deputy Alvaro Martinez. You recently introduced a bill proposing significant changes to the Gender Identity Law. Can you tell us what prompted this initiative?
**Alvaro Martinez:** Thank you for having me. The primary motivation behind the bill is to safeguard minors from potentially impulsive decisions regarding their gender identity. I believe that such significant changes should require a level of maturity and understanding that typically comes with adulthood. We often see minors influenced by external factors, such as societal pressures or media portrayals, which could lead to decisions they might not fully comprehend.
**Interviewer:** You mentioned that your proposal also seeks to prevent individuals with criminal convictions from changing their gender in official documents. Can you elaborate on why you believe this is necessary?
**Alvaro Martinez:** Absolutely. My concern is that allowing individuals with final criminal convictions to change their gender could complicate the judicial system. There have been instances where this process has been exploited, allowing some individuals to evade legal repercussions. For example, in certain femicides, accused individuals claimed a gender identity change to mitigate their punishment. This not only undermines the integrity of our judicial system but also erodes public trust in its functioning.
**Interviewer:** Critics might argue that your bill could hinder the rights of transgender individuals. How do you respond to those concerns?
**Alvaro Martinez:** I fully support the rights of transgender individuals, but I also believe in establishing a robust and clear regulatory framework. My proposal aims to ensure that decisions regarding gender identity are made with adequate psychological maturity and legal security. We need to protect not just individuals but also uphold the integrity of our legal system.
**Interviewer:** Can you discuss any specific requirements your bill establishes for changing gender in official documents?
**Alvaro Martinez:** The bill outlines that individuals wishing to change their gender on official documents must meet specific criteria that emphasize legal and psychological readiness. This is designed to prevent any potential abuses and ensure that changes are made thoughtfully and responsibly.
**Interviewer:** how do you see this initiative fitting into broader discussions about gender and law?
**Alvaro Martinez:** This initiative is part of ongoing conversations about the intersection of gender identity and legal regulation. It seeks to balance individual rights with the need for a fair and transparent judicial process. As society evolves, we must ensure that our laws reflect both advancements in understanding gender identity and the need for accountability within our judicial framework.
**Interviewer:** Thank you, Deputy Martínez, for sharing your insights on this important issue. We appreciate your time.
**Alvaro Martinez:** Thank you for having me. It’s vital that we continue discussing these topics openly and constructively.
